Views Don't Equal Fans

Attracting fans can be hard, especially for groups from small companies that lack the resources to go on big variety shows or have large performances. And even harder that getting that initial attention, is keeping it.
Social Media
Social media, if utilized in tangent with good music can work out very well. But my problem is when a company relies on social media to make a group go viral at the detriment of the music. I’m going to use X:IN as an example here because at the start they focused so much energy into short form content, and I will say that this worked to some extent because they are very funny. But, their music was not very good. So, even if a group is funny, and fans acknowledge that, so they go viral, at the end of the day, fans are not going to stick around long-term if the music isn’t good quality. Because at the end of the day kpop is centered on the music.
The second thing that I want to talk about with social media, is when companies make music specifically with the objective of making it go viral on social media. This is very much a problem everywhere, not just in kpop. Western artists also clearly make songs that are going to be used as audios on TikTok. The problem specifically with kpop, is when the music is made with the objective of one part being a dance challenge. My problem is that this can sometimes lead to bland choruses, or generic choruses, no matter how great the dance break is. This doesn’t always happen, but it is something i’ve noticed before.
Shipping Culture
Shipping culture is such a huge part of kpop, and I know from personal experience, that if there is a really popular ship, and I happen to see an edit, I might go and check out the group. Literally the reason I initially found out about Dreamcatcher was because of Suayeon, but because their music is very unique, and good, I ended up joining the fandom. Again, I am saying here that music is important. Even if there is one thing that gets someone interested in a group, if the music isn’t good quality, they are probably not going to stick around that long.
One unique factor
This can work out well, especially if they are filling in a missing gap in the industry, such as Dreamcatcher or xlove, so they attract fans that are looking for that specific type of music or concept. But again, this only works if the music and concepts are well done. If a fan decides that the music genre is not for them, then that is ok, but if the music is objectively bad quality, then that is where my problem is. I didn’t mention that so I just wanted to add that in here. Anyways, an example of a group that I think fumbled this method quite a bit was Blackswan. When they first debuted, they went super viral because of how diverse the group was. That is why I personally learned about them. But, their music has mostly been kind of meh, with only a few songs (in my opinion) that are genuinely pretty good, like Roll Up, or Karma. Because of this, I stopped keeping up with them, and I'm sure other fans have felt this way as well.
Problematic Behavior
When an idol will do something so obviously problematic, or the companies will force them to. For example I saw somewhere that small companies would sometimes make there idols wear very revealing clothing just to go viral. I believe an example of this is with Stellar. This is a “all press is good press” type of mentality. And, while it can work to get people talking, it is not going to hold attention long term.
Something I want to address is that I know I’ve been preaching about having good music is the best way to attract and keep fans, but the reality is that there are so many groups with such talented artists that are not getting the attention they deserve. So, honestly I can understand why some of them resort to things like this to get any sort of attention. That’s why it is our job as fans to promote hidden gems when we find them.



Comments