top of page

K-pop Positions: Helpful Labels or Unnecessary Limits?

Oct 10
3 min read
Display of the positions the Aespa members hold in the group
Note - this is not every position that each member holds, just the main ones they are known for.

Kpop positions have quite a few problems, so these are just some reasons why I personally think the idea of categorizing each member can be quite problematic. 


Visual Position:


I feel like visuals are either loved or hated in a group. Either they are loved simply because people can simp for them, or they are completely clowned on for their talents outside of being pretty. Regardless, 

imagine training for years to become an idol just to be put in a visual position where the company is essentially saying that all your good for is attracting attention with your looks. It completely undermines that actual work that goes into becoming an idol.


Rapper Position:


Rappers get almost no lines. Yes, most songs have a rap verse, but the rest of the time they are kinda just there. Also, rapping isn’t always exclusive to the rapper, so the company is splitting the single rap verse between four people so the rapper gets even less lines. It just doesn’t make sense because why have someone who specifically specializes in rap, just to not let them rap? Especially when the rapper is actually a good rapper, which isn’t always the case (i’ll get into that later). I also think that this has a lot to do with favoritism when the rapper isn’t as popular as the rest of the members, so their lines are just given away to other members. While saying this, I'm mostly thinking of Aespa and how everyone but Giselle seems to be rapping in their songs, and it genuinely makes no sense. 


Additionally, the rapper position often feels like a second though where it is just given to a random member because for some reason the industry feels the need to force a rap verse into every song even if it doesn’t make any sense. Like, if you insist on having a rap sanction, actually pick a trainee who specializes in rap, and is good at it. Yet it feels like whenever they do that, they rarely let the rapper actually rap. 


Main vs Lead:


This is just a personal thing, but I find it quite annoying when the lead vocalist gets more lines, or more difficult parts than the main vocalist. And i’m not talking about when the lead and main vocalists are essentially at the same level, but when it is clear that someone is a main vocalist yet all the likens are given to the more popular lead vocalist to the point where casual listeners think that they are the main vocalist. This is similar to my problem with rappers where if you have someone that is clearly significantly better than the other members, then why don’t you utilize them? And often it comes down to a popularity contest and I feel like if you are an idol and you are just competing with you fellow members for lines it could strain some relationships or create some resentment.


Sub:

This frankly feels worse than the visual or rapper positions because at least with them this is something distinguishing them from everyone else. But, for groups that are very large, there can be members with just a sub vocalist or dancer position, and they just fade into the background. If I was in a group and was just a sub vocalist I would just feel replaceable. Like I said earlier, imagine going through so much training just for your company to say “yeahhh…you can debut, but you're not good enough to be highlighted in the dances or songs, so we’re just going to say you are a sub vocalist and never give you any lines.”


Slight tangent, but this is my problem with large groups. It's harder for fans to connect with all  the members and actually get to know all of them, and there are so many members where the most popular member is going to get like half the song and the rest have to split the “one word repeating chorus” between like 8 members.

Comments


bottom of page